aethelwulf wrote:
Right, I have decided that I will most definitely not be watching it.
Sorry for digging up an old thread, but you started a thread about how bad RoP is without having watched it? If you're gonna criticize something to the point of starting a thread negatively, at least take the time to know your subject?
For me, trying to keep an open mind, the series started of not bad. Not great either, but the set design etc is amazing. The acting is good, and they clearly put ALOT of effort in getting dialect coaches. (I would argue the pronunciation of non-english words in the series is better than in PJ's movies.)
Furthermore, the dwarves are a highlight. They are lovely.
That being said, the story was messy. Needless changes to Galadriel's character made her close to insufferable the further into the season we go. The elven 'sickness' they invented and the need for mithril to 'cure' it blew my mind with how weird of a storydecision it was. Might be a ploy by Gil-Galad but the Gil-Galad we know wouldn't be like that.
The costumes were hit and miss. The dwarven costumes were great. The elven costumes mostly were too, but the hairstyle choices are baffling. Furthermore they chose to include actors of all ages for the elves, which doesn't make sense at all when it comes to consistency. Celebrimbor is a 50-something man, but Galadriel is around 30? The Sauron reveal was not only very obvious, but downright bad, and the forging of the rings, THE most important even for a series that's named RoP was rushed and anticimactic.
I don't know if I will watch season 2. I didn't hate watching season 1, but the further into the season, the worse the story decisions and writing gets. And that's a shame.
But I would like to distance myself from the horrible racism and misoginy and fatshaming and whatnot that the internetcommunity decides to throw at everything they don't like. I want nothing to do with them. Dislike a series for it's merit in writing and production, not the people involved.
My 2 cents!