aragorn would figth sauron

Azrael · **Posted:** Wed Jul 14, 2010 7:26 pm

Well even the troll they used instead of sauron would actually have smashed aragorn not later than when he stepped on his chest...

Highlordell · **Posted:** Wed Jul 14, 2010 8:44 pm

Sorry...I couldn't resist.

And yes that troll would have beated the %£&($! out of Aragorn had the ring not been destroyed at exactly that point.

GreenDragonInn · **Joined:** Wed Jul 21, 2010 9:43 am **Posts:** 56

Sorry to revive this post but I wanted to add my info.

I was watching the commentry by Peter Jackson and the Writers on the RotK DvD.

The idea was that Sauron wouldn't physically be there, but it would be more of a hologram or illusion that Aragorn would fight.

Not only that but it wouldn't be Sauron in his big epic black armour it would be the elf version, him former self and that they were going to make him the most beautiful man in all of middle earth. Kinda like Galadrials counterpart.

GreenDragonInn

CreatureFear · **Posted:** Thu Aug 05, 2010 6:46 am

GreenDragonInn wrote:

Sorry to revive this post but I wanted to add my info.

I was watching the commentry by Peter Jackson and the Writers on the RotK DvD.

The idea was that Sauron wouldn't physically be there, but it would be more of a hologram or illusion that Aragorn would fight.

Not only that but it wouldn't be Sauron in his big epic black armour it would be the elf version, him former self and that they were going to make him the most beautiful man in all of middle earth. Kinda like Galadrials counterpart.

GreenDragonInn

The form he used to decieve the Elves was called 'Annatar'. The scrapped film footage would have Sauron come forth as Annatar, blinding everyone. Then he would change into the 'Dark Lord' version and battle Aragorn - at different points in development it was literally him, then it wasn't, etc. (the idea is rather silly anyway)
All of this is mentioned and described in detail with the Special Edition.

GreenDragonInn · **Joined:** Wed Jul 21, 2010 9:43 am **Posts:** 56

they probaly had a 100 different ideas, all Im saying is that on the commentry, at the battle of the black gate, this is what Fran the main writer says.

Eorltheyoung · **Posted:** Sat Aug 07, 2010 12:20 am

Well Aragorn could not have even of fought Sauron because well........i n that case why didn't he just go after the One Ring himself.

osric · **Posted:** Sat Aug 07, 2010 12:52 pm

and if souron is enything like morgoth, then he could easily win. aragorn may be a good fighter, but there are limits.

CreatureFear · **Posted:** Mon Aug 09, 2010 7:00 am

GreenDragonInn wrote:

they probaly had a 100 different ideas, all Im saying is that on the commentry, at the battle of the black gate, this is what Fran the main writer says.

Wasn't saying that you were wrong - just saying what's on the extended and special editions.

SarumanTheWhite · **Joined:** Thu Mar 17, 2011 9:55 am **Posts:** 20

I own the extended edition and i do know about Sauron fighting Aragorn and then being replaced, but I think they were right to remove Sauron if you think about it, if sauron could come back to his old form, why ddi he do it at the black gate instead of being a freakin eye for about 2 ages.

Elros of Numenor · **Posted:** Wed Mar 30, 2011 5:59 am

Hehe

SarumanTheWhite, you may want to check the dates of previous posts before commenting on these sorts of threads... just a helpful hint.

aragorn would figth sauron

Who is online